How to choose the right smartwatch for you

Your wrist deserves the best.

a person using a smartwatch on their wrist
If you want to have a good time with your new smartwatch, you've got to make sure you pick the right one.Luke Chesser via Unsplash

Choosing a smartwatch is like selecting a smartphone, in that there are countless models to choose from. But that’s where the similarities end. While whatever handset you pick will be able to perform the same standard tasks—such as making calls, sending texts, and running apps—smartwatches offer a variety of functions and features, which makes finding the right one even harder.

We're here to dispel some of that confusion so you can choose the right smartwatch for your specific needs. From the different makes on the market to the blurring lines between fitness trackers and smartwatches, we'll outline the features you should be paying attention to before moving on to our picks for the best watches and fitness wearables out there.

Features to look for

For a smartwatch to be considered a smartwatch, it must be able to tell time—that much is a given. However, that’s just about the only constant in a field where the choices of features and functions range far and wide.

Top-tier smartwatches from Apple, Samsung, and Fitbit are essentially miniature phones that wrap around your wrist. They run pint-size apps, let you control your smartphone remotely, and are capable of phone-like tasks such as tracking your run around a park, storing music, and even making phone calls through a tiny SIM.

On the next level down, you’ll find devices that are basically fitness trackers with a display: They focus on logging steps and other activities while treating smartwatch features as a bonus. These devices can tell time and sometimes show simple notifications from your phone—but interactions are limited, which means you’ll need to pull out your cell for most tasks. While they may not be as capable, they often cost much less.

Another category that’s emerged over the past few years is a traditional, mechanical watch with a few added smarts. These devices typically include features such as basic step counting and maybe a simple notification system, too. You’ll get the style and price of a normal watch, with the bonus of a little bit of fitness tracking.

Whichever category you lean toward, check for a few key specs. One is whether the watch works with your phone (iOS or Android); another is how long the battery lasts (mechanical watches are still ages ahead here). Also, check that the watch has the features you want. For example, runners and sports enthusiasts might want to look for standalone GPS, which will let your wrist-based device track your location even when it’s not connected to your phone. Swimmers who want to record their progress should keep their eyes out for waterproof smartwatches. Really consider what will work best for you.

Of course, form and comfort should also factor into your decision. If you’re going to be wearing the watch a lot of the time, you’ll want to make sure it’s comfortable. So visit a retail store and try a few smartwatches on for size, or check a selection of online reviews. You’ll get an idea of the look of a smartwatch through pictures, and reviews should help you find details about its feel and weight on the wrist.

Now that you know what to look for, here are some of our top picks:

Apple Watch

two Apple Watches, Series 5
The Apple Watch Series 5 features an always-on display, a first for the Apple Watch.Apple

Arguments continue, but the general consensus seems to be that the Apple Watch is the most advanced smartwatch you can buy right now. It interfaces seamlessly with the iPhone, offers a host of mini apps, and excels at health and fitness tracking.

You can use an Apple Watch to look up future calendar events, listen to music, regulate your breathing, send messages, and even chat with Siri. It’ll also track your activities and push you toward your fitness goals. Going further, it can act as a remote shutter for the camera on your connected iPhone, and you can even make and receive calls through it—either via your iPhone over Wi-Fi, or directly, if you opt for a more expensive LTE model.

The newest Series 5 models start at $400 and come with built-in GPS, a heart rate monitor, and water resistance down to depths of 50 meters (164 feet). The new models come with an always-on display too, so you won’t have to raise your wrist to see the time. The major downside is that these watches only work with iPhones—so if you’ve got an Android device or think you might want one in the future, the Apple Watch won’t cut it.

Wear OS

a young man wearing a Fossil smartwatch and lifting up his sweatshirt
Ah yes, 10:56 a.m.: the perfect time to lift up your sweatshirt to show everybody your surgery scar.Fossil

Wear OS (previously Android Wear) smartwatches are essentially Google’s alternative to the Apple Watch. Made by a number of manufacturing partners, like Fossil and TicWatch, they do most of what an Apple Watch does. However, they’re more flexible—not only will they work with Android phones, they’ll also connect to an iPhone, though you won’t get the same level of interactivity (you can’t reply to texts from your wrist with an iPhone like you can with an Android phone, for example).

All the big smartwatch features are here, including viewing notifications and sending messages from your wrist, tracking your activities and fitness goals through Google Fit, listening to music, logging your location (for GPS-enabled devices), talking to Google Assistant, and more. Some models also include support for 4G LTE via a small SIM slot, which means you’ll be able to make and receive calls without a connected phone.

As with Android phones, you’ve got a broad choice of smartwatches to pick from. Prices typically fall somewhere below the Apple Watch level—the Fossil Gen 5, one of the most expensive Wear OS flagships, retails for $295 on Amazon. Just double-check the specs for features like a heart rate monitor and on-board GPS, as some Wear OS watches include these and some don’t.

Samsung Tizen

Samsung Tizen Galaxy Watch Active2
Samsung's latest Tizen smartwatch is the Galaxy Watch Active2.Samsung

Once in the Wear OS camp, Samsung has struck out on its own with its homemade Tizen operating system for smartwatches and various other devices. The company makes some of the best wearables in the business, with the advantage that they work just as well paired with either an Android or an iOS phone.

The Tizen smartwatch interface isn’t quite as polished as those offered by Apple Watch or Wear OS, but in terms of features and functions, it’s just about on a par. You can track activities, view calendars, get notifications, cache songs to play on your morning jog, and even make calls with the SIM-enabled models. You will, however, miss out on a few native functions, like the Apple Watch’s ability to reply to text messages from your wrist.

The latest offering from Samsung is the Galaxy Watch Active2, available in two slightly different designs for $280 (40-millimeter model) or $300 (44-millimeter model). There’s a strong focus on health and fitness, as with the Apple Watch, and the Active2 can track the quality of your sleep, too.

Fitbit wearables

some Fitbit Versa 2 smartwatches suspended in the air
Fitbit's newest smartwatch is the Versa 2.Fitbit

Now that Google has purchased Fitbit, the brand might be one of the most interesting to keep an eye on in terms of future smartwatches. It’s far too early for any fruits of that deal to appear, but further down the line we might see the long-rumored Pixel Watch from Google with Wear OS on board.

Right now, Fitbit’s flagship smartwatch is the Fitbit Versa 2, which you can pick up for $200 from Amazon. It’s great at tracking health and fitness activities, but doesn’t have some of the more advanced smartwatch features, such as on-board GPS. All of Fitbit’s watches and fitness trackers work with both Android phones and iPhones, so it’s a good option for those who may switch between mobile platforms.

Fitbit has been in the wearables game for a long time, of course, and its mobile apps are some of the best for keeping tabs on steps, calories, and sleep. At the same time, they’re getting better at other functions, too, like smartphone notifications. Watch this space for what Google and Fitbit do next.

Outdoor sports watches

a black Garmin Fenix 6 smartwatch
The Garmin Fenix 6 is about as feature-packed a smartwatch as you're likely to find.Garmin

If you take your running and hiking more seriously than most, a separate category of smartwatch exists just for you. No one has officially labeled it, but many refer to these devices as outdoor sports watches. They’re bigger and more rugged than other designs and tend to focus on navigation and activity tracking rather than mini apps or digital assistants. Take a look at some of the watches offered by Garmin or Casio to get an idea of what we mean.

These watches don’t offer proper app platforms, like the Apple Watch or Wear OS do, but will show most notifications from your phone (like calls and calendar entries), and they have a host of other features to make up for what they lack. For example, the top-end Garmin Fenix 6 can measure your heart rate, track your steps, direct you home (or anywhere else) without a connected phone, and give you advanced performance metrics beyond the reach of most smartwatches.

You’ll have to pay a premium for wearables in this category (the Fenix 6 starts at $600, though cheaper Garmin watches are available) because they offer the most detailed fitness tracking and most advanced integrated navigation to outdoor sports enthusiasts.

Hybrid watches

a Withings hybrid watch
Hybrid watches combine traditional mechanics with activity tracking.Withings

As if you didn’t already have enough options, we finally come to traditional mechanical watches with some extra smarts inside, often known as hybrid watches. If you’re already used to a low-tech watch but like the idea of a little extra functionality, give one of these models a try.

Lots of traditional watchmakers are putting out devices in this category now. To give you two examples, we like the $200 Withings Steel HR Sport or the $195 Fossil Hybrid HR. Both of these models can track your steps, monitor your heart rate, alert you to some phone notifications, and even get your phone to ring if you’ve misplaced it.

As you can see from the prices above, traditional-style watches tend to be cheaper than dedicated smartwatches. Another advantage is that, because they use standard watch batteries, they don’t need to be recharged. For those with a foot in both the old and new watch camps, they’re an ideal option, and they’ll happily work with both Android and iOS too.