Evolution might be the reason your boss is a jerk
Posted 10.07.2008 at 5:45 pm
4 Comments
The Boss
iStockPhoto
Whether you've had to make last-minute photocopies, cough up the last three dollars in your wallet to fetch coffee, or have your brilliant idea shot down in a meeting, everyone has had at least one boss who has been, let's face it, beastly. According to a new study, this behavior can be traced back to the hunter-gatherer days of our prehistoric ancestors.
Using evolutionary psychology, researchers at the University of New South Wales found that much of the behavior high-level executives exhibit mirrors the territorial personality of long-extinct tribes. Bosses show signs of male domination: in "protecting their turf," they ostracize nonconformist or disagreeable group members, intimidating all of their employees into adhering to a certain framework of acceptable behavior. The leader does all that he or she can to prevent being threatened by any upstarts or whistleblowers. The study found that meetings are usually held in the most senior manager's office, and he/she controls the agenda. Instead of sitting at their desks, bosses make the rounds, learning who is friends with who, participating in meetings, and leveraging their positions. Just knowing that your boss could come around the corner at any moment probably keeps you off of personal email and your favorite blogs. Perhaps as a sign of an overall unwillingness to leave their posts, managers in this study rarely take midday breaks, while staff takes full advantage of their lunch hour. Even bullying, while in no way a condoned practice in the workplace, is more understandable when placed in a tribal framework.
In a way, this is modern tribalism -- the strongest group is the tightest group. Though much of this behavior is no longer necessary to propagate the species, it has been thoroughly ingrained over two million years of biological evolution. If anything, the study proves that it is no simple task to change our behavior. Encouraging productive teamwork will take more than a couple of trust falls at the corporate retreat. Researchers believe that sharing these findings and making people aware of the often subconscious actions they take in the office is one way to improve trust and bring people on every step of the company ladder closer together.
The study, led by professor Jeffrey Braithwaite, focused on health workers, but its findings can be broadly applied to any number of industries. The report, published in the Journal of Health Organisation and Management, is the result of hundreds of interviews and countless hours of observation carried out over a 15-year period. The next time you feel like rolling your eyes at a boss who just won't give you a break, blame it on evolution -- or a lack thereof. Besides, you always knew your boss was part-Neanderthal.
[Via EurekAlert]
4 Comments
To comment, please Login.
Download Our iPhone App
Stay up to date on the latest news of the future of science and technology from your iPhone with full articles, images and offline viewing
Follow Us On Twitter
Featuring every article from the magazine and website, plus links from around the Web. Also see our PopSci DIY feed
Become a Fan On Facebook
Share links with friends, comment on stories and more
November 2009: Astronaut 3.0
Inside NASA's astronaut bootcamp and the grueling new training regimen for deep space. Plus, ten young geniuses shaking up science today, one writer's quest to analyze every man-made chemical in her body and more.
Check out the issue's full contents online here
Popular Science Photo Pool
Popular on Popsci
Most Viewed
Science
- Baguette Dropped From Bird's Beak Shuts Down The Large Hadron Collider (Really)
- Hideous Rodent May Provide Cure For Cancer
- Fermi Space Telescope Captures Glimpse of Space-Time
- My Quest To Analyze Every Man-Made Chemical In My Body
- So Just How Tiny Is a Virus?
- Gallery: Where Toxins Come From
- Kissing Evolved To Spread Germs, Not Feelings
- A Material Based on Sharkskin Stops Bacterial Breakouts
- How To Fix a Broken Collider: the LHC's Restart Checklist
- Gray Matter: The Hidden Uses of Everyday Explosives
Most Commented
Science
- Baguette Dropped From Bird's Beak Shuts Down The Large Hadron Collider (Really)
- This Week in the Future, October 26-30, 2009
- Hideous Rodent May Provide Cure For Cancer
- This Week in the Future, October 30- November 6, 2009
- Fermi Space Telescope Captures Glimpse of Space-Time
- Kissing Evolved To Spread Germs, Not Feelings
- My Quest To Analyze Every Man-Made Chemical In My Body
- A Material Based on Sharkskin Stops Bacterial Breakouts
- Mutant Bacteria Are Likely to Threaten Future Space Travelers
- Lawsuit Banning Human Gene Patents Continues, Court Rules
Most Emailed
Science
- My Quest To Analyze Every Man-Made Chemical In My Body
- Kissing Evolved To Spread Germs, Not Feelings
- Fermi Space Telescope Captures Glimpse of Space-Time
- This Week in the Future, October 30- November 6, 2009
- Nanoparticles Can Damage DNA Without Crossing Cellular Barrier
- Mutant Bacteria Are Likely to Threaten Future Space Travelers
- Digital TV Switch A Boon For Astronomers
- Will a Shortage of Nuclear Isotopes Mean Less Effective Medical Tests?
- Baguette Dropped From Bird's Beak Shuts Down The Large Hadron Collider (Really)
- New Genomic Zoo to Collect DNA of 10,000 Vertebrate Species
Today on PopSci.com
Copyright © 2009 Popular Science
A Bonnier Corporation Company. All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.
from New York, New York
Haha, great story.
"...much of the behavior high-level executives exhibit mirrors the territorial personality of long-extinct tribes." Does this mean, then, that the less-evolved climb the corporate ladder more quickly (tribalistic instincts at work)? What does that say about the corporate world? Food for thought.
"Encouraging productive teamwork will take more than a couple of trust falls at the corporate retreat." Someone finally said it. Here, here.
OMG I just hate bosses that are jerks dont you?
www.anonymity.at.tc
I am not sure I agree with the findings.
At one time, I was the owner of a small business and was very controlling and angry with my employees.
I found however, that my anger issues stemmed from growing up in a dysfunctional family and harboring a lot of resentment.
I was able to work through my issues by attending recovery classes at my church that were written by a Christian psychologist. ( Making Peace With Your Past by Tim Sledge & Celebrate Recovery by Rick Warren)
I am now able to deal with my issues in a healthy way and no longer feel the need to “protect my turf”. The need to be controlling and in charge has turned into a need to be compassionate, understanding and caring.
I do not believe if it was instinctual I would be able to change my behavior.
I believe most people grow up in family with some sort of dysfunction and carry those issues with them until they choose to deal with them, and until they do everybody around them has to pay the price.
from Broomfield, Colorado
"I am not sure I agree with the findings.
At one time, I was the owner of a small business and was very controlling and angry with my employees.
I found however, that my anger issues stemmed from growing up in a dysfunctional family and harboring a lot of resentment.
I was able to work through my issues by attending recovery classes at my church that were written by a Christian psychologist. ( Making Peace With Your Past by Tim Sledge & Celebrate Recovery by Rick Warren)
I am now able to deal with my issues in a healthy way and no longer feel the need to “protect my turf”. The need to be controlling and in charge has turned into a need to be compassionate, understanding and caring.
I do not believe if it was instinctual I would be able to change my behavior.
I believe most people grow up in family with some sort of dysfunction and carry those issues with them until they choose to deal with them, and until they do everybody around them has to pay the price."
First of all you have used anecdotal evidence. You may have had a dysfunctional childhood, but not all mean bosses have had dysfuctional childhoods.
Second. Instictual behavior does not mean you can't change your behavior. It is a human instinct to procreate and yet some people choose to live celibate lives under their own free will. Isaac Newton was one