The plastic tube Sandy Hawkins hands me looks more like a toy horn than a medical device. Blowing into it, he tells me, will do wonders for my chest cold. I glance at the dozen or so people enjoying their mid-afternoon Starbucks and give it a few skeptical puffs.
The idea for the horn came one night in 1985. Hawkins, an acoustics engineer, and his colleagues began brainstorming how they could use sound to mess with various bodily functions. They joked about what frequency a toilet would need to vibrate at to force an uncontrollable bowel movement and, slightly more seriously, a way to dislodge goo in sick people’s lungs. Months later, Hawkins was reminded of that discussion when he learned that chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), a group of lung diseases that includes emphysema and chronic bronchitis, makes breathing tough for 10 million people, and causes 127,000 deaths in the U.S. every year. “It’s the number-four cause of death in the U.S.,” he says. “I thought, ‘Yeah, I should do something about this.’ ”
In healthy lungs, hairlike cilia on the bronchial walls wiggle in unison to ferry mucus up the trachea and into the mouth, where it can be swallowed or spit out. Patients with COPD, however, secrete more mucus than the cilia can remove, and thick gobs of the stuff build up in the lungs, making them a breeding ground for bacteria that can lead to pneumonia. Vigorous coughing can help dislodge it, but many sufferers require drugs to open their airways; some need help from oxygen tanks. Annually, the combined cost of treatment totals upward of $27 billion.
Hawkins began building an electronic sound machine that would produce waves of 16 hertz—the same frequency at which the cilia move—to help break up the mucus. Generating a hum of such a low frequency normally requires van-size subwoofers, and so he spent 15 years honing and shrinking the speakers. Then one day as he was testing a mouthpiece filter for his machine, he noticed that blowing through it sent a slight vibration into his chest. Within five seconds, he sketched out the Lung Flute to amplify the effect. Blowing into the tube flaps a reed-thin sheet of plastic, which vibrates the chest and shakes the mucus until it’s thin and mobile enough for the cilia to usher it up your throat. “I felt so stupid because the answer was so simple,” Hawkins says.
Today, doctors in Japan use the $40 Lung Flute as a tool to collect sputum from patients suspected of carrying tuberculosis, and in Europe and Canada it’s used to help test phlegm for lung cancer. Clinical trials in the U.S. have shown that it is at least as effective as current COPD treatments. At press time, Hawkins expected the device to receive FDA approval any day, and says the reusable device could also provide home relief for patients with cystic fibrosis, influenza and asthma.
As Hawkins tells me all this, I notice that my cough has become more productive, and although he deserves my congratulations, I can’t stick around to chat. Instead, I head outside and march to a storm drain to resolve the situation. —Corey Binns
Video: Lung Flautist Bjorn Carey shows us how to play
(Photo: Charles Eshelman)
How can I buy this item, anybody know?
I just read that it has passed FDA 501(k) for use in laboratory analysis and pathological examination. There is not info about it being available to the regular consumer yet, but it does state when it is available, it will require a prescription from a doctor.
It will require a prescription from a doctor? How much does the government have to do to get an outcry from the public. If the banjo is found to help arthritis will we need a prescription for those it helps to get one?
Wow this thing seems really neat , great invention . When I read that you would need a prescription to get one I thought , huh , why ? Tis doesnt seem to make sense to me seeing how it just a mechanical device that appears to be harmless . You dont need a prescription for a steamer thing you can buy for bronchitis .
But after thinking about it , they can do what they want on this one , my guess is it wont be cheap , I'll just let my medical cover it
I say the future of healthcare is too make everything we can cheaper and easier to do from home. If we could develop simple inexpensive systems to test for disease and ailments then we could skip doctor checkups and only go in once we've found something wrong. That would clear out a lot of space and time.
Make an I dunno.... compact micro spectrometer that can be updated online for any new ailments that checks blood, saliva, urine or whatever... I mean you can generally tell when you have a broken bone or something but having a home diagnostics system that could also tell you the basic treatments for a disease could save lots of money across the board.... insurance would be cheaper... doctors could be more specialized... this is probably the solution to all our healthcare woes...
Just thinking... not really related to lung flute....
Maybe they think you should have a prescription because, for now, they don't know if vibrating those tiny hairs to much could cause damage to them.
A prescription would mean that at least you would have to talk to a doctor about how much is considered safe.
Later on, after people have been using it for a while and there aren't any lawsuits... maybe then they would deem that there was no need for prescriptions.
It's apparently cleared for home use in Canada and the European community. My feeling is that due to the litigious nature of the US and to be able to legally state the claim about it's intended use, Medical Acoustics had to get the FDA approval and have it delivered by prescription only.
It's a bummer though. I thought it would be good for even more minor ailments such as congestion due to colds and allergies.
If i could score a schematic I would print one out to try.
.
Um, you could download the patent with the diagrams...
"Device and method for inducing sputum"
US Patent 6702769
www.freepatentsonline.com/6702769.html
HTH,
-- K.H.
Where can one procure it and is it re-usable ?
It could probably have been marketed by 'As Seen on TV' with no problem. But then, no one would have believed them.
However, if they want to sell it as a serious medical device, it has to go through FDA requirements. The FDA reviews the submission of test data to ensure that the devices acually work.
They also inspect the manufacturer to ensure that they're making good product.
As for the prescription status, the FDA is supposed to move drugs off of this status whenever possible. I would think that they have the same charter for devices.
The solution is simple. Make a one note musical instrument with the same basic design. Then cover the hole with your finger to get the same vibrations as the lung flute. Anyone can design and make one and the FDA would not be able to do a thing about it. The FDA is way out of bounds on this device. Will we soon need a Rx to play a saxophone, harmonica, flute? They all vibrate? Stupid people. A simple device that can relieve a lot of suffering being held-up by a bunch a bureaucrats.
Hey, I'm looking for a partner for a business that buys gold at 52% and sell it at full-price. Interested. I need around $50,000
Contact me at ernie@cash4goldtomorrow.com and I will send you an executive business plan.
Or call 801-687-4515
I think this would be great for people with Cystic fibrosis
I hope that someone is testing this somewhere.
from Los Angeles, CA
Before I saw the video of the flute being used (below), I was under the mistaken impression that this device generated some kind of loud noise, which it does not-- its only resemblance to a real flute is its shape. If it did generate loud noises, I could imagine several reasons you might want to control it with prescriptions-- but this thing is hardly audible! It makes me angry that we have more bureaucratic nonsense preventing this device from being used on a broad basis! It would not surprise me at all if this flute started being bootlegged like CDs, name-brand watches, and sneakers.
KISS: Keep It Simple, Stupid. Thank you for doing exactly that, Mr. Hawkins, even if the medical establishment wants to muck it up for those of us that might actually need it.
16 Hz is below the audible range except for the youngest and most sensitive ears. Actually, this frequency is also in the range (<20Hz) being used to stimulate bone growth, etc., for osteo patients and astronauts. Very little volume/power is required.
If you can get speakers to produce that specific sound, sit in front of one with your spittoon ready. :)
Or, for that matter, if you can overlay two sounds in the audible range (easier for ordinary speakers to produce) which are 16Hz apart, the "beat frequency" should work just the same. E.g., 500Hz and 516Hz.
I registered for an account just to comment on this. I would pay good money for this device for home use. As a life long asthma sufferer -- though not somebody where it is severe enough to require a nebulizer -- I've always wanted something that could do this. I also suffer from chronic pneumonia, well, chronic in that just about every time I get sick, I get pneumonia and it wipes me out. I'm otherwise very healthy and exercise regularly, but I'm just so freaking sick of getting pneumonia and other lung/chest conditions, I'd kill for something like this.
This is for Sandy if indeed he reads this type of feed back and hasn't already thought of the idea.
The biggest problem most industrialized citizens face is "not enough sleep". This is not for the sleepers but their spouses. Snoring is a huge problem that has wide ranging effects.
The question:
Can acoustic engineering solve the problem. The noise generated from the relaxed throat tissues while sleeping should be able to be counter acted by acoustics such that the noise is eliminated from dis-harmony (breaking up of the vibrations to cause no sound at all).
two things screw up the pulmonary system
1- upper chest breathing,wch is v.inefficient for O2 uptake&puts stress on the heart as well as the intercostal muscles.
FIX- learn&practice abdominal/diaphragmic breathing
2- eliminate all dairy
www.notmilk.com
&
video.google.com -Dr.McDougall's 'Marketing Milk and Disease'
NB
suffered for decades of panic&pain due to lung problems wch proper breath technique& diet have eliminated