Four tips for bake-off worthy cakes

You might not get on TV, but the people you feed will appreciate your work.
A person using a piping bag to pipe frosting onto a chocolate cake.
You'll need real skill and training to do something like this, but you can always improve with a little practice. American Heritage Chocolate/Unsplash

This story was originally featured on Saveur.

For no-fail, sky-high layer cakes, like the fluffy Southern cakes from Ben Mims’ story Southern Dreams, there are a few simple rules to follow. These four tips will help you produce perfect cakes every time.

Start with cake flour

A photo of a box of cake flour with a yellow cake with vanilla frosting on the front.
Cake flour is, unsurprisingly, great for cakes. Todd Coleman

All-purpose flour isn’t really made for every purpose. For the best results when baking a cake, you need to use cake flour, a finely milled and typically bleached variety of flour made from soft winter wheat. With a lower content of gluten-producing proteins than in all-purpose flour—around 7 percent versus 10 to 12 percent—cake flour yields baked goods with a fine, soft texture. The bleaching process also raises the acidity of the batter, which allows the starch in the flour to absorb more moisture, further enhancing the cake’s tenderness. Although cake flour is readily available at grocery stores, in a pinch, you can substitute three-quarters of a cup of all-purpose flour mixed with two tablespoons of cornstarch for each cup of cake flour called for in the recipe.

Keep out the cold

Seven eggs in a glass bowl of water.
A bowl of warm (not hot) water will quickly raise the temperature of refrigerated eggs. Todd Coleman

The key to a smooth batter is making sure the milk, butter, and eggs are at room temperature when you mix them into a cake batter. Chilled eggs and milk can harden softened butter when they’re mixed in, resulting in a curdled appearance. Whereas butter and milk can be microwaved to soften—a shortcut that works but is not ideal due to the risk of overheating—you can’t microwave eggs without cooking them. Ideally, you should leave the eggs out overnight so they can come to room temperature naturally. But if you are pressed for time, you can quickly warm up refrigerated eggs by placing them in a bowl of warm tap water. The cold eggs will cool the water right away, so drain the bowl and refill it with more warm tap water. Let the eggs sit in the water for about five minutes so that they reach the proper temperature before adding them to the batter.

Just beat it

A Sunbeam stand mixer working on a glass bowl of cake batter.
It’s OK to beat your cake batter for a bit. Todd Coleman

When it comes time to mix the ingredients, a bit of counter-intuition helps: Most home bakers learn not to beat their batter in order to prevent the formation of gluten, which leads to a tougher crumb. While this may be a concern when using all-purpose flour, cake batter is less prone to gluten production. And beating a cake batter for a short period of time actually helps smooth and aerate it. Once the batter is just mixed, beat it on high speed for five seconds. You will notice that it immediately transforms into a smooth emulsion, ensuring that the ingredients are evenly dispersed.

Finish with a bang

A person dropping cake batter in a cake pan onto a hard surface, like a counter.
Drop it like it’s… cake batter? Todd Coleman

Finally, most bakers dread the random air bubble that wreaks havoc on a sliced cake’s appearance. But this type of aesthetic imperfection can be avoided by dropping the pan on a countertop to burst any air bubbles. Once you pour your batter into the pan, smooth its top with a rubber spatula. Next, drop the pan from the height of about a foot onto countertop. The impact of the fall will force large air bubbles out and settle the batter into the pan, producing a more even shape. Only do this for cakes leavened with baking soda or baking powder, however; egg foam cakes, like genoise, need their air bubbles in order to rise.