Ten Dollars Is Not a Lot to Pay for All of the Music Ever

A 1281 Bill Bettencourt

Share

According to the RIAA’s yearly sales report, which was released this week, this year for the first time Americans are buying as much digital as physical music. Great!

But here’s the thing: people are buying digital (meaning, without a physical aspect, unlike a CD, which is also digital) music in all the wrong ways. The vast majority of this music is being bought as iTunes-style downloads. But, my friends, subscriptions are the best, most futuristic option for buying music right now–and they’re dirt cheap.

This isn’t an ad. I don’t care if you use Spotify or Rdio or MOG. (And, obviously, none of them are paying me. My allegiance is solely to you people.) But there’s no denying that this is the way we should be buying music in 2012: a pittance of a monthly fee gives you unlimited access to basically all music, ever. You can stream it from your computer. You can stream it from your phone. You can stream it from your tablet, or your TV, or your car. Any music, any place, any device, any time. It is amazing, and it’s actually sort of surprising that it only costs ten dollars–the same as one album on iTunes. And yet when I try to convince people to join one of these services, the response is often “well, if it wasn’t ten dollars a month, I might.”

Are you kidding me.

Here’s what ten dollars buys you.

  • You might buy a medium-decent sandwich. A regular-sized combo at Wendy’s, depending on where you are and what you order, costs about five bucks, or two weeks of unlimited music (the latter option has zero calories, we should note). A nicer sandwich, like the meatloaf sandwich from ‘Wichcraft I’ll probably get for lunch today, costs $10–a full month. If you live in an expensive place like New York or San Francisco, you probably drop ten dollars on lunch without thinking about it.
  • Or you could go drinking! Beers in New York cost between four and eight dollars. (In less silly places in this country, that’ll often be a dollar or two lower.) Two beers–not even a night out!–will cost you as much as the ability to listen to any song ever recorded, like you’re a god damn superman from the year 3000, for an entire month.
  • You could buy one album on iTunes or Amazon. I’m not a mathematician, but if I reach far back, further back than college, further than high school, I can dig up this equation:
1 (album) < ∞ (albums)

* You could get one ticket for

John Carter

, which is shaping up to be one of the bigger flops of the year. It’s a movie in which Tim Riggins jumps very high and kills Martian grasshoppers in a way that somehow squanders the collective promise of Tim Riggins, Mars, giant grasshoppers, and high-jumping. Or you could have a month of music. * You could buy one week of medium plain coffees from Starbucks. This is probably going to hurt my argument, but if you’re seriously doing that I would suggest holding off on a music subscription and

getting your life in order

first. If you’re drinking that much Starbucks you’ve got more pressing issues to deal with than music cost. * Cigarettes in New York are poetically priced to gouge smokers so thoroughly as to induce an existential crisis upon the purchase of every pack. A month of music is considerably better for your long-term health and is actually cheaper. You won’t look

as

cool but you’ll still look pretty cool. (Note: New York has the most expensive cigarettes in the country, according to

this unscientific but informative survey

. But even in states like West Virginia and Idaho, two packs’ll still run you as much as a month of music.) * At the airport, a bottle of Dasani water and a small bag of trail mix, which you will leave half-eaten in the pocket of the seat in front of you when you get off the plane, costs between nine and 12 dollars. For about the same price, bring a water bottle and subscribe to a music service. It’s environmentally friendly and you’ll be able to listen to the complete discography of Hall & Oates while you fly (assuming you’ve thought ahead and synced ever H&O album to your phone before you left the house). * Next time you need cash, try to find one of your bank’s ATMs. Because if you use someplace else’s, you’re paying for about two weeks of unlimited music–and you’re not even getting anything for your $5. With a subscription service, you could just crank “Private Eye” while you walk the three blocks to your actual bank. (Note to self: stop listening to so much Hall & Oates.)

sequin portrait of Khloe Kardashian
  • Now for the crowning metric: for the price of a six-month subscription, during which time you will have the time and power to listen to the entire ’80s output of Verified Geniuses John Hall and Daryl Oates, you could also buy a portrait of Khloe Kardashian made with melty plastic circles.
 

Win the Holidays with PopSci's Gift Guides

Shopping for, well, anyone? The PopSci team’s holiday gift recommendations mean you’ll never need to buy another last-minute gift card.