A physicist claims that the "ghost particles" of our world could help communicate with underwater submariners

Run Silent Run Deep Submarines of the future could get a communications upgrade U.S. Navy

Submariners should brace for some crazy science to match those Crazy Ivan maneuvers. A physicist says that ghost-like neutrinos that pass easily through just about everything could provide a future method of communication with deep sea submarines.

Neutrinos represent the ghost particles of the physics world that typically pass through about every form of matter without a trace. That solves one half of the problem in communicating underwater, where radio waves travel poorly and even very low frequency (VLF) waves can only go so far. But it leaves open the other half of the issue in that submarines have no way of receiving communications via neutrinos.

Physicists have typically studied such particles by detecting the secondary particles or electromagnetic waves that result from rare neutrino collisions. They have also used an experiment at the Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory in Chicago to beam neutrinos more than 435 miles to a Minnesota mine, where a giant underground detector can easily pick up the muon particles that result from neutrino collisions--although even that detector has only found 730 muons over the past two years of operation.

Patrick Huber, a physicist at Virginia Tech, believes that the next generation of muon detectors will dramatically improve in sensitivity to the point where a submarine could possibly carry one. Covering a submarine hull in thin muon detector modules could possibly work, but an even easier method might involve looking for the Cerenkov light radiation left by muons moving through seawater. That large signature could represent an easier target for detection, despite interference from the usual light in an underwater environment.

There are several ifs, and yet the idea of receiving data at rates of up to 100 bits per second must sound appealing to naval forces. Submarines that want to communicate without surfacing must currently trail a long radio antenna behind them, and can only receive up to 50 bits of data per second.

But even if a neutrino communication method arises, Technology Review points out that there's still no way for submarines to phone home in reply. So for the near future, submariners may have to settle for the usual: run silent, run deep.

[via Technology Review]

Want to read more articles on the military, aviation, and space? Subscribe to Popular Science today, for less than $1 per issue!

4 Comments

"But even if a neutrino communication method arises, Technology Review points out that there's still no way for submarines to phone home in reply."

Neutrinos produced using nuclear reactors which nuclear submarines already have.

fb36, i think the problem isn't producing a neutrino here and there so much as projecting an intense, tightly focused "beam" of them, right?

There is no need to focus the neutrino beam, just like radio antennas radiate in all directions.

All you need to do is increase and decrease its intensity (probably by adjusting the energy output of the nuclear reactor) to produce "bits" of communication.

But still I disagree w/ that physicist.
I think even next gen detectors would not have enough sensitivity. Probably next of next gen would be required!

"There is no need to focus the neutrino beam, just like radio antennas radiate in all directions."

That's generally the case for low-gain antenna. High-gain antenna however, are directional and transmit in a focused beam.

In addition to 'gain', there is the difficulty controlling neutrino output enough to produce a signal that is coherent enough to be read.

Interesting concept, but not worth researching purely for apllication to submarine communication. The US government has enough on its plate. I wonder what other possible applications exist, though.


138 years of Popular Science at your fingertips.

Innovation Challenges



Popular Science+ For iPad

Each issue has been completely reimagined for your iPad. See our amazing new vision for magazines that goes far beyond the printed page



Download Our App

Stay up to date on the latest news of the future of science and technology from your iPhone or Android phone with full articles, images and offline viewing



Follow Us On Twitter

Featuring every article from the magazine and website, plus links from around the Web. Also see our PopSci DIY feed


February 2012: The Future of Fun

Science is reinventing play, from extreme sports to gamification to ridiculous roller coasters to the playgrounds of tomorrow, and this issue is chock full of fun. Also, on a less fun note: Did global warming destroy my hometown?


circ-top-header.gif
circ-cover.gif