How does the pufferfish stay inflated? Not by holding its breath, a pair of Australian marine scientists discovered. Previously, scientists thought pufferfish stopped taking in oxygen through their gills while they were inflated. Instead, the fish supposedly took in more oxygen through their skin.

Yes, this sounds exactly like the kind of explanation you make up on-the-spot when your five-year-old asks, “What makes the fishie puff?” and you just bought her that ice cream cone you told her she couldn’t have, and now you can’t afford to lose any more credibility. (“But then how does it breathe?” “Through its skin, dear!”) The idea that pufferfish hold their breath came in part from observing a species called the Obscure pufferfish, which keeps its gill-flap closed while inflated.

To check this assumption, biologists Georgia Evelyn McGee of James Cook University and Timothy Darren Clark of the Australian Institute of Marine Science putted out into Australia’s Great Barrier Reef. They netted eight black-saddled pufferfish and took them back to the Australian Institute of Marine Science. At the institute, the biologists put their fish into custom-built respirometers and then simulated the presence of a predator by applying light suction to the fish and squeezing them gently. That does sound pretty creepy, from a pufferfish point of view. All the fish puffed in the usual way, by gulping water into their stomachs.

photo of a black-saddled pufferfish, not inflated, in an aquarium

Black-Saddled Pufferfish, Deflated

McGee and Clark found that while inflated, the black-saddled pufferfish didn’t take in much oxygen through their skin. Yet the oxygen levels in the water around them kept dropping, and the fish moved the flap above their gills, indicating they were taking oxygen in through their gills. This is the first time scientists have found evidence pufferfish continue to breathe through their gills while inflated, McGee and Clark wrote in a paper, published today in the journal Biology Letters.

So pufferfish aren’t necessarily slowly fainting while they’re puffed. Still, it’s not nice to make them inflate. After inflating, McGee and Clark’s fish took an average of five hours and 36 minutes for their metabolisms to return to normal. Experiments performed in other pufferfish species show they get so tired from repeated puffing, they can’t do it anymore after three to eight times in a row. Tell that to the next kid you see tapping on the glass at the aquarium.