Gray Matter
A dramatic demonstration -- with exclusive video! -- of why the same gas that heats your house can also make it explode

Whooomph! Mike Walker

Living in the Midwest, where heating homes with propane is common, I periodically see reports in the local paper that yet another unoccupied house has exploded. They often note that the roof was found in the basement, while the walls were spread some distance into the neighboring fields.

Roof-in-basement syndrome begins when propane, which is heavier than air, leaks and fills up the lower levels of a house, mixing with the home's ambient air. Once the layer of gas reaches the height of a pilot light in a stove, it triggers a huge explosion. (The refinery adds a very strong odor to propane, so if people are home, they typically notice the leak before the concentration approaches a dangerous level.)

Why does the same gas that burns gently in a furnace turn into an explosive menace when it leaks? Without oxygen, propane can't burn. You could light a match inside a propane tank, and nothing would happen. Furnaces control the rate of burning by mixing propane with air slowly as it burns. But premix large amounts, and the results are very different.

The Setup:  Mike Walker
To show this, I filled soap bubbles with hydrogen gas and lit them with a lighter. (I used hydrogen because it makes the bubbles float, so they're safer to light at a distance. Propane bubbles would sink.) Pure-hydrogen bubbles burn quietly as the hydrogen mixes with air and burns over several seconds. Fill the bubbles with a mixture of hydrogen and oxygen, though, and what was a gentle whoosh becomes a chest-thumping bang. When fuel and air mix in advance, the entire volume of gas burns in a fraction of a millisecond -- which is to say, it explodes.

I've done this demonstration several times with people unfamiliar with just how much power can be tied up in a few soap bubbles. I've never actually blown a window out, but I think I have knocked a few socks off.

Making Hydrogen Bubbles

THE SETUP
High-pressure tanks of hydrogen [red] and oxygen [yellow] supply the raw elements for this demonstration. What keeps it safe are devices at the ends of the hoses called flashback arrestors that prevent the gases from mixing inside the canister.

Achtung! Theodore Gray is trained in lab safety. Don’t try this at home. See more of Gray’s work at periodictable.com.

Want to read more articles like this, plus tips and tricks, home hacks, DIY projects, and more? Subscribe to Popular Science and enter to win $5,000!

13 Comments

Why does a Hydrogen and Oxygen mixture explode? wouldn't it turn into water?

It does turn into water. Just after releasing a lot of energy. A water molecule has less energy than the components that make it up. This is where the extra energy of the explosion comes from. Coincidentally, this is also what allows hydrogen fuel cells to work. The reverse of this process is possible by the application of energy, most notably in the electrolysis of water to generate pure hydrogen and oxygen.

Nice demo,but a little misinformation re the propane.

1.You could drop a match into a propane tank -- well, you can't because it's pressurized and mostly liquid (That's what the L in LP stands for).

2.The propane explodes because there's so much of it available. In the furnace, only a small amount is exposed. So, the story doesn't really relate to the demo.

3.'Natural' gas, which is lighter than air, also causes home explosions when a leak occurs -- and they are amazingly violent.

@ ford2go

1. IF you could drop a match in a propane tank it would not explode, the IF should have been mentioned in the article though.

2. In a leaking furnace the gas slowly seeps out and mixes with the air until it is set off.

3. Propane does the same thing when a leak occurs.

The article relates just fine.

generic_me01

from Syracuse, IN

Gaffe Alert: "You could light a match inside a propane tank, and nothing would happen."

But would a match light in the first place with no oxygen present?

First, the article says to light a match inside, not drop in a lighted match. Thus the match is already inside the pressurized tank when it is struck.

Two, part of a old-fashioned "Blue Tip" matches have oxidant already mixed in, like gunpowder, but slower. That was the lighter blue art at the very tip. Thus you can light one in a vacuum - of course, when the oxidant runs out, the fire stops. But it's enough to ignite propane, if it will ignite. (As a kid I used to whack them with a hammer and get a nice bang, just like little gunpowder "caps" for cap guns.)

Hydrogen and methane will also collect, mix, and explode, but they gather at the ceiling and work down to the pilot light. However, many houses are permeable enough that the mixture leaks out faster than a small leak can replace, while propane just pools (unless your house is on a hill and the cellar door leaks) - thus the methane never reaches the pilot light. In a nice tight house, or with a big leak, yes: big boom.

Wow dude, now that looks like a lot of fun!

RT
www.anonymity.eu.tc

my physics teacher in high school used to have 2 special days every year when he would come in dressed as dr fire or dr ice and we would spend the whole day blowing things up or freezing them. he would fill balloons with different mixtures of gasses and set them off. one explosion was so big it blew all the ceiling tiles in the front of the room out. loved it.

yeah in my 8th grade class we did hydrogen bubbles, it was great, still have burn marks in the ceiling tiles. we did also play with dry ice and liquid nitrogen i love that stuff.

this is very similar to an experiment i conducted recently wherein i farted in the bathtub while smoking a cigarette.

We used to make hydrogen balloons with a glass Coke bottle, aluminum foil, Drano and water. It would fill a punching balloon 2' in diameter. Instant Hindenburg! The reaction is exothermic which is why you need the heavy glass bottle and the heavy rubber punching balloon.

drayegon

from Redding , CA

Most kids in science class remember this type of thing best because it is exciting and fun. If the teachers in all of the kids classes helped the kids to make school work this much fun how much more could all the kids learn.

You don't think that Math can be that much fun? Make the math problem something that has the kids competing against one another.

Same thing with English try seeing how much funny it would be to learn how to write a really good short story.

When teachers finally learn. HOW TO TECH. Then we will have a lot more really intelligent students graduating from all their classes.

dray

Dawsone1996

from Louisville, CO

I think that using gasoline would be way cooler. Let's see a video of that!

Popular Tags

Regular Features



Download Our iPhone App

Stay up to date on the latest news of the future of science and technology from your iPhone with full articles, images and offline viewing



Follow Us On Twitter

Featuring every article from the magazine and website, plus links from around the Web. Also see our PopSci DIY feed



Become a Fan On Facebook

Share links with friends, comment on stories and more


December 2009: Best of What's New

In our December issue, Popular Science names the 100 best innovations of the year: bombproof wallpaper, self-parking cars, the fastest helicopter, and 97 more. Plus inventor profiles and videos.

Check out the best of what's new here.

Popular Science Photo Pool


Share your photos in the Pop Sci pool at www.flickr.com!
tags_sprite.png
POP_embeddedForm_cover_May09.jpg

Events and Promotions