If you want to avoid pit stains or are just a bit uneasy about using aluminum to keep your pits dry, you may have been tempted by “natural”deodorants. You may have also been disappointed by their efficacy. Below, aluminum-free deodorants that actually work—for us anyway.

A basic option. Amazon

Check Price

Schmidt’s aluminum-free deodorant rolls on well and has a smooth consistency. It comes in an unscented option, but if you prefer to smell like something nice, opt for the bergamot and lime, cedarwood and juniper, or lavender and sage varieties.

Easy to bring with you on trips. Amazon

Check Price

If you’re worried about getting stains on your clothes from roll-on deodorant, Source Vital is a good choice. It’s free of aluminum and baking soda and contains citrus and spearmint essential oils. It’s clear and lightweight, so you won’t have to worry about getting marks on your clothes. If you’re traveling, be sure to put it in your checked bag, since the 4.3-ounce size is too big for carry-ons.

The clay-like consistency helps keep you dry. Amazon

Check Price

PiperWai comes in a jar, and you apply it with your hands. It has a thick consistency that softens with your body’s natural heat. The activated charcoal helps to absorb the body’s sweat and odor. It also has a refreshing, but not overpowering, scent. Even though it takes a little longer to apply, it will last for the full day.

Change how you smell. Amazon

Check Price

Native uses wholesome ingredients like shea butter, tapioca starch, and fractionated coconut oil (which is less messy and absorbs more easily into your skin than regular coconut oil). This deodorant comes unscented or with scents like citrus and herbal musk, coconut and vanilla, and cranberry and plum.