• Entertainment & Gaming

    Desktop Linux – Will It Ever Stick?

    By Tom Conlon Posted on 4.2.2009 33 Comments

    About seven years ago, I tried to free myself from the oppression and misery of running Windows ME by installing Linux on my PC. Ever installed the Linux operating system? It’s not for the faint of heart. So, when it was recently reported that Linux-based netbooks are being returned at a rate four-times higher than their Windows-based brethren, I can’t say I was surprised.

    Article Rating:
    11.9.2008 at 03:15pm - Comment by Eric Freedom

    Linux is not hard to learn to use. My 87 year old father learned to use Linux and liked it better than Windows. Linux is not Windows Linux anymore than Mac is Windows Mac. I found switching from Windows to Linux to be easier than I found switching briefly to a Mac I had been loaned when I had hardware problems. That doesn't make the Mac interface bad. There is a tone among the respondents that Windows is the standard and Linux must live up to the standard. Wake up. Windows is a far from perfect standard. Windows users simply accept with little thought the problems they have with Windows: lack of support - unless you are a mega business; lack of security; viruses, trogin horses and spyware that slows machines to nearly a halt; and a bloated Vista OS that requires half the processor power of a dual processor computer while the other half does the work you need your computer to do. Vista is too bloated to run on an Eee. Even Windows PC magazines damn Vista as a terrible OS. Nor is Linux perfect. When I adopted Linux I thought mounting and unmounting drives was a very good idea and not difficult for even this computer retard to manage. But in 2001 hardware driver problems were a real issue. I simply accepted that I would have to make sure any equipment I bought had Linux drivers before I bought it. Now Linux has no more driver problems than Vista has, but that means there are still problems. And there are other problems as well. Far fewer though, than the problems encountered in the Windows world. I say this because, though I am not a geek, I do hang out with geeks who make their livings as system admins. Windows is their cash cow. Repeat customers. One of these geeks encourages people to try Linux. Those who do stop being repeat customers and he only hears from them when they buy a new computer. Another problem with Linux is that most people use Windows and save their data in proprietary formats rather than Open Standard formats. For the most part Linux programs deal with these formats seamlessly, but to share your data with people in the Windows world you have to save your data to formats their programs can handle because their programs are less flexible than your programs are. The numerous Linux distributions (flavors, like flavors of icecream, what flavor do you prefer) and the wide variety of choices in user aps is NOT a problem, though several respondents have referred to it as a problem. This is what gives Linux its strength, utility, and rapid innovation. However, I empathize with being overwhelmed by reading names of programs you have no clue about about. I went through it when things were even more obscure, but I didn't have to choose from ignorance. Back in 2001 I simply chose the standard installation rather than the custom installation. Today Linux programs are better known and as mentioned above, some notable ones are available to Windows and Mac users. If you are fearful of all this choice, simply choose the most popular Linux flavor, currently Ubuntu, and you will have a complete desktop with solid easily usable user aps to do all the tasks you are used to doing with a computer. From this stable beginning you will be able to explore and decide whether you like the standard Ubuntu installation or prefer this or that other program to do this or that task. Googling will not just get you support but allow you to find out what other people like and do not like about various programs, and you will come to form your own opinions about which programs suit you best. So what problems do you want to deal with? I chose the problems I would encounter in the Linux world because I would not click "I agree" to the XP end user license agreement. I had had problems with Windows before I switched and I had problems with Linux after I switched. Just different problems. You will find it to be the same today. I would not give up the Freedom and choice I have in the Linux world for anything the Windows world has to offer me, and I will never again put up with the viruses, trogan horses, spyware, and security problems of the Windows world. Again, what problems do you want to live with?

  • Entertainment & Gaming

    Desktop Linux – Will It Ever Stick?

    By Tom Conlon Posted on 4.2.2009 33 Comments

    About seven years ago, I tried to free myself from the oppression and misery of running Windows ME by installing Linux on my PC. Ever installed the Linux operating system? It’s not for the faint of heart. So, when it was recently reported that Linux-based netbooks are being returned at a rate four-times higher than their Windows-based brethren, I can’t say I was surprised.

    Article Rating:
    11.7.2008 at 07:47pm - Comment by Eric Freedom

    While I am glad PS is exposing its readers to Linux I wish some misconceptions were not passed along. First, Linux programs are far easier and safer to install than Windows programs. Program installations are taken care of by a package manager. Open the package manager program, click on the program you want, and it is automatically installed over the web from a SECURE repository. I challenge anyone to install from scratch Windows and associated user aps in the 45 minutes it will take me to install Ubuntu Linux on that computer. Only geeky programs very few people use require the installation procedures described in the article. Xandros Linux is installed on the Eee, probably because it is windows like in appearance. I didn't like it, so I installed Ubuntu Eee instead (Linux). Wireless wasn't working (that bug is no doubt fixed by now) and I had to do a web search to find a solution. I'm no geek, but I could follow the "cookbook" instructions. Someone new to Linux would be wise to find a Linux geek to hold their hand through the process of installing and making sure everything works. The usual 45 minute process took me two hours. Ubuntu Eee is VERY COOL and worth the trouble of installing. It is far cooler than the Windows or Xandros versions the Eee comes with. The interface is fabulous, and Ubuntu Eee is a full Ubuntu installation with the whole range of user aps Linux users are used to. That is like having a Windows power user's desktop installation installed on an Asus Eee. (I'd like to see someone try that!) Though the Eee is not a hardware powerhouse, my daughter uses her Eee as her sole computer. She can do this because Linux makes very efficient use of hardware. She does everything a typical college student does, excluding tasks requiring high processor power, so no fancy 3D games, or major video edits. Windows users new to Linux will find many familiar programs: Firefox, Skype, Open Office (Microsoft Office replacement), GIMP (Photoshop replacement), Pidgin (user interface to use all the IM services someone may be subscribed to all at once). Windows users could save a lot of money if they stopped thinking of brand name aps and instead thought about what tasks they want to accomplish. When I switched from Windows to Linux in 2001 I owned about $600 worth of programs. In the Linux world I found equivalent or better programs and have spent exactly $0 on software since 2001. I am living proof you do not have to be a geek to use Linux. When I switched to Linux in 2001 I didn't even save my data to a hard drive because I didn't know how I would ever find it. In the intervening years I have tried mightily to be come a Linux wizard, but I have failed laughably, and now there is no point to it. Ubuntu Linux is mindless to install and it just works. Even hardware drivers, which were an issue in 2001, are a very minor issue now. In fact, Ubuntu Linux has fewer problems with hardware than Vista does. Readers need not fear getting involved with Linux.



Download Our iPhone App

Stay up to date on the latest news of the future of science and technology from your iPhone with full articles, images and offline viewing



Follow Us On Twitter

Featuring every article from the magazine and website, plus links from around the Web. Also see our PopSci DIY feed



Become a Fan On Facebook

Share links with friends, comment on stories and more


December 2009: Best of What's New

In our December issue, Popular Science names the 100 best innovations of the year: bombproof wallpaper, self-parking cars, the fastest helicopter, and 97 more. Plus inventor profiles and videos.

Check out the best of what's new here.

Popular Science Photo Pool


Share your photos in the Pop Sci pool at www.flickr.com!
tags_sprite.png
POP_embeddedForm_cover_May09.jpg