• Entertainment & Gaming

    Are Records Really Better?

    By Posted on 7.3.2008 18 Comments

    Sorry, vinyl aficionados, but CDs most accurately capture the clarity of musical performances. If you look at the grooves of a standard long-play record, or LP, through a microscope, you’ll see that each is filled with what look like rolling hills. These are, in fact, an extremely close replication of the shape of the sound waves from the musician’s instrument. But because the needle that carves the groove is shaped slightly different than the needle that reads it, the LP will never sound exactly like the original performance.

    7.4.2008 at 05:18am - Comment by CuriousGeorge

    I came across a link a few months ago from a private research site called DHF (dhf-masterworks.com), which purports to have developed a rendering process for producing compressed audio of a higher listening quality than CDs. Yeah, we've heard this before and normally I wouldn't give such a thing a second look, but in this case I took it seriously enough to visit. I've been listening to the developer's classical internet broadcasts for a few years now on Live365's Baroque.FM and also his new WCCB (wccb-classical-fm.com), and am mightily impressed by the detail and warmth of the mp3 streaming there. What's this got to do with the CD vs. Vinyl debate? I myself listen mostly to classical and jazz, and am a serious vinyl audiophile. On the other hand, with the emergence of the ipod and like I've also become a music-phile, wanting to have all of my music portable. Until now I haven't found a happy medium so I listen to my high end system and vinyl at home, and 'make do' with my ipod on the go. Now it seems there may be a 3rd alternative emerging in DHF-type audio that may offer the best of both worlds. As for CDs, they were great as a 'make do' given their durability and portability during 80s and 90s, but given their high price and lack of resonant depth and harmonics, I can't see buying any more of these when a much more compact and higher fidelity alternative may be available out there. I have no idea what the scientific basis for DHF is, but I know what I hear and IMHO DHF is definitely much closer to vinyl than CDs ever got.



Download Our iPhone App

Stay up to date on the latest news of the future of science and technology from your iPhone with full articles, images and offline viewing



Follow Us On Twitter

Featuring every article from the magazine and website, plus links from around the Web. Also see our PopSci DIY feed



Become a Fan On Facebook

Share links with friends, comment on stories and more


December 2009: Best of What's New

In our December issue, Popular Science names the 100 best innovations of the year: bombproof wallpaper, self-parking cars, the fastest helicopter, and 97 more. Plus inventor profiles and videos.

Check out the best of what's new here.

Popular Science Photo Pool


Share your photos in the Pop Sci pool at www.flickr.com!
tags_sprite.png
POP_embeddedForm_cover_May09.jpg