World's First Robot Census Prompts Existential Robot Questions

What is a robot?

By Dan Nosowitz Posted 10.12.2010 at 12:00 pm 4 Comments

PR2 Pairs Socks

At Carnegie Mellon University, one robotics student estimates that there are more robots than students in the department, but in a shameful display of mammalian arrogance, the precise number and type of said robots is unknown. That realization led the student, Heather Knight, to begin the world's first robot census.

Knight, a graduate student in robotics (Carnegie Mellon is the only school in the country to offer a degree program in robotics), began by counting the 547 robots present on the CMU campus, not including its government-run satellite lab in which several hundred secret robots are estimated to be languishing. But that was only the beginning.

The quest to document robots spread from Carnegie Mellon to the Makers, a community of DIY enthusiasts organized loosely by MAKE Magazine and its accompanying Maker's Faire events. Knight put out word on the census through the Makers, and set up her own online census, which, it should be noted, is far more in-depth than the U.S. government's census. It asks for such information as "functional category" (companion, medical, entertainment, research), "degree of local intelligence," and the dates of both conception and birth.

But all this analysis of robots prompts a more existential question: What exactly is a robot? Knight's own three "minimum, but not sufficient" requirements are as follows: "They must act in the world, sense the world, and they need to have computation." But, as Technology Review notes, that rather broad list allows smart home appliances, like dishwashers, that demonstrate some degree of autonomy. The census itself doesn't really address these issues: If you think your creation qualifies, then by all means, fill out the census.

It's a great project, not just for its inherently amusing format but for its ability to bring the robotics community together, showing these makers what else is out there. And it's serving to bring more attention to robotics, which Knight says is a struggle in the west, due to the Terminator. (I notice, for what it's worth, that "time-traveling cyber assassin" is not listed among the possible categories.)

Here at PopSci, we've got our own little informal census going, including Mars-bound robot planes, an utterly bizarre dancing swan, a vaguely racist bow-and-arrow-wielding archerbot, and, of course, military robots that lie through their figurative robotic teeth.

[Robot Census via Technology Review]

Previous Article: In New Attempt to Build a Practical Military Laser Weapon, Lockheed Inverts a Prism

Next Article: Confirmed Exoplanets Could Reach 500 by the End of This Month

4 Comments

Link to this comment

Maersikai

10/12/10 at 2:22 pm

Time-traveling cyber assassins really needs to be one of those catagories.

Link to this comment

quantumwarrior

10/12/10 at 4:59 pm

@Maersikai Agreed.

www.dotgeekblogs.blogspot.com

Link to this comment

trireme

10/12/10 at 7:53 pm

We have to build Terminators to stop Skynet, then Cylons to stop the Terminators, then Daleks to stop the Cylons. Then somewhere down the line we need HAL to destroy them all. Hail our robot overlords!

Link to this comment

weapongeek

10/22/10 at 9:01 pm

yo trireme you don't need HAL to stop the daleks just get the doctor, he do the job and make it look cool

Popular Tags

Technology

All Tags All Photos All Videos

Technology

+ More Photo Galleries

June 2013: American Energy Independence

Five amazing, clean technologies that will set us free, in this month's energy-focused issue. Also: how to build a better bomb detector, the robotic toys that are raising your children, a human catapult, the world's smallest arcade, and much more.