Life-Detector Test A fuel cell could detect the presence of life on other worlds by measuring the redox reactions that happen in the metabolic process. Technology Review

If life exists on other planets, it won't necessarily have the same carbon-based metabolism we do, so detecting its presence will require some sophistication. Now, a group of Argentinian researchers say they've come up with a method that will work to detect any form of life.

Ximena Abreyava and colleagues suggest using a microbial fuel cell, which could detect life in a way that is independent of its chemical makeup, according to Technology Review.

The only requirement is that the life form in question must have a metabolic process of some sort -- it must take chemical energy from its environment and use it to power itself. Consisting of an anode and a cathode, the fuel cell can detect the redox reactions of metabolism, which generate electrons and protons.

An anode is embedded in the medium to be investigated -- Martian soil, for instance. It captures the electrons generated in the reduction-oxidization process. Protons pass through the membrane, completing the circuit. The amount of current flowing through the cell is a direct indication of life.

The fuel cell test needn't focus solely on carbon-based life forms, which could come in handy if we ever send one to Titan,, which may harbor methane-based life.

The Argentinian team tested their contraption by comparing the results it produced from life-containing soil with sterilized soil. They say the power and current densities were much higher when the anode was embedded in soil samples containing life compared to samples that had been sterilized, according to Tech Review.

Not since the Viking Mars landers in the 1970s have planetary explorers been set up to look specifically for life forms. Instead, they've searched for water and other materials considered essential to life. The Viking landers sent back false positive results, essentially because Mars' oxidizing environment tricked their life-hunting instruments.

Tech Review points out that the fuel cell test could lead to other false positives, if the sterilization process changes the soil chemistry in a way that reduces the power flowing through the fuel cell. The concept needs more work, but it's a step toward a life-detector test for other worlds.

[Technology Review]

6 Comments

Since all life on Earth requires water, wouldn't the test more or less be driven by the water or other conductive particles present in certain life-forms? Water conducts electricity more readily than sterilized dirt, or am I incorrect?

The whole point of the test is that it side steps the assumption about water being a prerequisite for life. Who knows what metabolic processes life might use on other planets. Since humans can't be there you have to design a test that is not to specific

Battleshield. Popsci JUST did a story on new discoverys on Titan leading to the possibility of methane based life. Methane my friend is not water! You kinda answered your own question. You said all forms of life on Earth. We aren't really looking too hard for ALIEN life on Earth.

If they came up with a method for detecting intelligent life, they'd be on to something.

The problem would be testing it on Earth. You'd have to find at least some small sample of intelligent life to test it on.

How would the system differentiate between plain chemical or metabolic reaction...

like what if the soil is alkaline or acidic??

@inaka_rob
You realize the term "methane-based" has nothing to do with the idea that water is needed to support life? Afterall, life on Earth is not water-based it's carbon-based.



June 2013: American Energy Independence

Five amazing, clean technologies that will set us free, in this month's energy-focused issue. Also: how to build a better bomb detector, the robotic toys that are raising your children, a human catapult, the world's smallest arcade, and much more.


Online Content Director: Suzanne LaBarre | Email
Senior Editor: Paul Adams | Email
Associate Editor: Dan Nosowitz | Email
Assistant Editor: Colin Lecher | Email
Assistant Editor: Rose Pastore | Email

Contributing Writers:
Rebecca Boyle | Email
Kelsey D. Atherton | Email
Francie Diep | Email
Shaunacy Ferro | Email

circ-top-header.gif
circ-cover.gif