Playing Around
Don’t write off the desktop just yet

World of Warcraft Lives Is the PC passe? The 11.5 million monthly subscribers of the most massive online game don't think so. Courtesey Blizzard Entertainment

In an era of high-definition, online interconnected systems like the PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360, will PC gaming go the way of coin-operated arcades? According to market research firm The NPD Group, sales of PC games precipitously declined to $701 million in 2008, a 14 percent year-on-year drop. But is the sky really falling for desktop users? A deeper look suggests not, pointing to a hobby that’s instead evolving so rapidly it would make Darwin blush.

Anticipated retail releases like Starcraft II and Diablo III promise to reinvigorate the category in 2009. But more importantly, the pastime is undergoing a renaissance on the unlikeliest fronts. Free Internet browser-based outings, streaming content delivery services and copy protection-free online software libraries continue to experience meteoric growth. Massively multiplayer online (MMO) universes from World of Warcraft to MapleStory and Club Penguin are also enjoying ballooning interest from all ages, and expected to be a $13 billion market by 2011. Likewise, casual downloads such as Westward III and Totem Tribe prove that hours of fun don’t always come in a cardboard box. Technological advancements in data storage and transfer have prompted an uptick in user-generated, or homebrew, content as well. See City of Heroes’ upcoming custom mission creator, or Spore, whose fans have designed over 75 million creatures and objects in under six months.

Independent titles are growing in stature, and pushing the boundaries of experimental design. See underground smash World of Goo a quirky physics-based puzzler, or Love, an Internet universe where computerized routines let you remodel entire landscapes and build or destroy anything in sight.

Even hoary old staples like the text adventure and 2D point-and-click epic, holdovers from the Apple II era, are enjoying new life after years of neglect. Courtesy of software emulation, mobile handsets such as the iPhone as well as netbook and laptop computers are further helping players reacquaint themselves with the classics. The phenomenon helps to explain a sudden upsurge in interest surrounding so-called “abandonware” sites (Google it for instant gratification), where players can—not so legally—retrieve bootleg copies of out-of-print titles. Don’t forget the continued availability of episodic outings either, or bite-sized game releases delivered in regular installments like television shows.


So the next time a smack-talking friend rolls their eyes and demands you finally ditch your mouse and keyboard in favor of a wireless controller, don’t be afraid to defend your poor old desktop. Simple figures based solely on retail sales may tell part of the story. But not the entire tale of a platform that’s still home to some of the most exciting, diverse and groundbreaking game developments.

Get Rich Playing Games (getrichgaming.com) author and TV/radio host Scott Steinberg has covered technology for 300+ outlets from CNN to Rolling Stone. For more of his insights, visit www.gadgetexpert.net.

15 Comments

RanoOnay

from Salt Lake City, Utah

I have always been more of a PC gamer than a console gamer. For one, PC games give a lot more customization like controls, new content, creating your own content, etc. Plus a Computer gives you more functionality as well. Its not just a game system, its also your Contacts list, calendar, email, word processor, and the list goes on. Plus don't forget some of the amazing titles that have been on the PC: SimCity, Diablo, Star Craft, Quake, Crysis, WOW, just to list a few, and upcoming games like Starcraft II, Diablo 3, Star Wars TOR and the list continues. I personally will always be a PC gamer, wish they'd come out with more for the Mac.

I wish you could use a mouse and keyboard for consoles during gameplay, I prefer using a mouse for shoot 'em ups and for RTS games

Another thing that makes computers sell fewer games that is not mentioned here is that it is easier to illegally download computer games than games for any other system.

bdhoro87

from coral gables, fl

Surprising you guys didn't mention valve and the steam system for downloading online games. Full games like Left 4 Dead are available for purchase and you simply download it to whatever computer you're using, the consoles have yet to release full package games through download, you still have to go to the store and pick up a disc.

its not dieing its just resting it will wake up soon (i hope)

i find pc games to be too expensive to play

i mean, you need a gaming pc to play and compared to ps3 or xbox360 why would you?

myself, im not buying a 2k laptop to play gears of war2 when i can get a xbox360 for less than 500

palarious

from Detroit, Texas

A PC can be so much more than a console. For $500 dollars, if you know just a piddling about computers and know how to type newegg.com, you can create a PC that can function as a dvd player, tivo, internet, work(autocad programs, word, excel), artwork(photoshop type work, media manipulation), storing photos and backing up records, and much more all while being displayed on your personal choice of monitors or even your HD television at full 1080p.

Oh, and did I mention that games tested on both well-equiped PCs and consoles run smoother, look better, and contain more customization on the PC.

And your computer can constantly be upgraded. Your PS3 or 360 will just get old. No use even popping one of those open.

I agree with palarious, computers will always be more powerful than gaming consoles and in the end, you get something that can do so much more.

Anyone who writes off PC gaming has never played for real! computers are so much better than consoles will ever be, we all know that (rite..). Like mikesicalieber said "you get something that can do so much more". You mite notice my pic at the moment and think wow hes lame he play combat arms but in the end who can turn down a bit of free FPS...

rosegarden

from Coupeville, WA

Let us not forget that the open architecture of Sony's Play Station has permitted some very far reaching science to go forward. Specifically, the project completed by a student at MIT using chained PS3s to calculate the settling time of a black hole excited by absorbing mass (such as a star, for instance. Linking together the PS3s permitted creating a very inexpensive super computer.

Let's not forget that ALL Games are designed on the computer as well.. They get ported to Consoles, they are native to PCs.

Gaming will never die because it is directly responisble for pushing forward the developmental boundaries of electronic technology.

If Consoles want to leave computers behind, they will have to conquer things like propritary hardware / software, develop a native programming language, and become modular / upgradable. At that point is it really a console anymore, just another version of the computer.

Personally I prefer, upgradabilty, customization, and multi-funtionality. Computers ... EPIC WIN

an1sh

from Toronto, Ontarion

Sooner or Later PC Gaming WILL die out.

Reasons:

-Portability- I.E, Laptops will take over desktop computer and people find this more convenient than going for a desktop computer. Game devs will be forced to create games that are designed for playing on an average laptop computer

-Pirating/Illegal Ownership of games- If the game devs don't come up with a special fix to prevent mass torrenting and downloading of games, Many games will not be distrubuted to PC for fear of accumulating loses in devs perspective

-Inconsistency in Power of PCs: Game devs will get a hard hit on this one since not many people can own a high end desktops to play very powerful resource hogging games. As a result some people will buy a game and some won't and this could result in losses due to production and other stuffs

-Compatibility: Many devs will face a massive hurdle when it comes to coding/designing for different OS, and it would take very long to create a game that is enjoyable as standards rocket sky high as years goes by. THey will find it easier to code/design a game that is played on a console that has the same power as the other millions of other consoles.

I might have missed other key points, but I feel the above points would result in dying of PC gaming.

bdhoro87

from coral gables, fl

an1ish,

You completely missed the entire point and how many of your points actual work better against your argument.

I just bought a laptop for $500 and have been able to play many new games and run them smoothly (this laptop came with a Nvidia geforce 8200 gfx card) and i can take my laptop anywhere and play. I can even play the online multiplayer games in most places since wifi is around everywhere.

Many video game companies already have key securities in place to prevent pirating and illegal ownership. Systems like Valve's Steam as I mentioned before adequately restrict the ability of unauthorized users to play. The security on computers is only getting better too, where-as I know of people who have gotten their xbox's modded to play copied dvd's.

What you call the inconsistency of the power of pc's is actually the constant competition pushing on the limits of the abilities of pc's only making them better and better, while even next-gen consoles can occasionally maybe get a software update. As i mentioned before any cheap new computer can probably play the newest computer games out and that's the advantage for PC games. Also game developers are already invested in advanced computing technologies for testing games (while writing code can be done on a much simpler machine.)

Also PC seems to be the exclusive OS for most computer games (which seems to always be referred to as PC games) as opposed to the many different OS's they work with when modding games from the PC's they're written on to the 3 various next-gen consoles as well as the portable consoles PSP and Gameboy.

This consistency in OS leads to a more gradual increase in development skill and ability which coincides with the Market in this industry - computers constantly gradually get better, as well as the software that is produced which fuels the market. That's why PC gaming will lead the gaming market for a long time.

Kraez

from stamford , ct

I personally like the whole customization of PC's. Ok.. yes i have a Wii. I love it cause its a new innovative way at playing video games that can't at this point be replicated on a PC. I love my Wii.. But im in love with my PC. Back to customization. xbox.. hmmmm... maybe like 10 buttons with a d-pad and a couple of analog sticks. PC... a whole keyboard plus mouse with 3 buttons ( in my case 5 buttons.) Most PC games allow you to arrange the keys to whatever command you would like them to be. Left handed... Right handed.. I don't know if im making any sense here but. Consoles are basically confined to the few command abilities that they give you.. I'm not even going to get into the mouse in first person shooters vs. analog sticks. get real. mouse players wipe the floor with any console controlled players in any game hands down and blindfolded. im goin off on a tangent

o.O; i think i may have just confused even myself...

So don't get me wrong, I love console gaming too (I still play my NES & N64), but it is really obvious that computers have been and always will be more powerful.
The major problem with consoles is the frequency in which they become obsolete. Every year it seems there is a new system out. So you may spend more than enough for a really nice computer each time you buy the new version of the console. The reason is because consumers want better graphics, more features, and more involved gameplay but that becomes more hardware intensive needing more powerful consoles. At 300-500 a pop each year (or 18mo or so) that becomes pretty expensive. I can't imagine them getting cheaper as time goes on.
With computers sure, you have the same problems but since it's modular you can replace parts when the need arises. There is no need to buy a whole other console. My brother plays World of Warcraft quite a bit so he needs a good computer. I play the Steam games. I went and fully upgraded my computer for under 400 bucks. I now have 4GB RAM, a Dual Core AMD processor 2.6Ghz, and a video card I had to get a 500W power supply for (I burned out a cheapo 450W in like 2 mo--thanks China)



Download Our iPhone App

Stay up to date on the latest news of the future of science and technology from your iPhone with full articles, images and offline viewing



Follow Us On Twitter

Featuring every article from the magazine and website, plus links from around the Web. Also see our PopSci DIY feed



Become a Fan On Facebook

Share links with friends, comment on stories and more


December 2009: Best of What's New

In our December issue, Popular Science names the 100 best innovations of the year: bombproof wallpaper, self-parking cars, the fastest helicopter, and 97 more. Plus inventor profiles and videos.

Check out the best of what's new here.

Popular Science Photo Pool


Share your photos in the Pop Sci pool at www.flickr.com!
tags_sprite.png
POP_embeddedForm_cover_May09.jpg