Feature
The Big Question: Why are galaxies moving toward the same point, as if pulled by an unknown force?

Dark Flow Dark flow is the mysterious phenomenon behind whole clusters of galaxies moving as if pulled by an unknown point outside the visible universe. McKibillo

As if the universe weren’t strange enough, scientists have recently discovered that entire galaxy clusters—the largest known structures in the universe, consisting of thousands of galaxies—are moving toward the same area. And we have no idea what mysterious phenomenon is drawing them along. Whatever it is, it’s huge. So far, cosmologists’ best guess is that it’s the gravitational pull from something beyond the visible universe. NASA scientist Alexander Kashlinsky and a team of researchers discovered the mystery motion, dubbed “dark flow,” last year. Dark flow joins other cosmological mysteries, including dark matter and dark energy, none of which are easily explained by Einstein’s general theory of relativity, our current best theory of how gravity and the universe itself work. Solving even one of these riddles could turn physics on its head.

Dark Matter vs. Dark Energy:
Dark Matter is the name of the invisible mass that creates the gravity required to hold galaxies together.
Dark Energy refers to the force that’s causing the universe to expand far more rapidly than math suggests it should.
 McKibillo


Instant Ph.D.

Essential Jargon

Visible Universe: In the first 380,000 years after the big bang, any photons created were immediately re-absorbed, which means there was no light in the universe. Because light takes a certain amount of time to reach us, that 380,000-year period is the wall that determines how far into the past, and thus how far out in space, we can see. Although it’s probably impossible to directly observe anything beyond the visible universe, phenomena like dark flow, which may show the influence of very distant structures on the universe we can see, can help us reconstruct what’s out there.

Captivating Statistic

46.5 Billion Light-Years: If Kashlinsky is correct, that’s at least how far away the source of dark flow lies from Earth. The most distant object ever observed was a gamma-ray burst from a dying star 13 billion light-years away.

What's Next

Scientists will try to figure out if all galaxy clusters are susceptible to dark flow. If so, we’d know that its cause stretches back to our universe’s beginning, lending credence to the theory that something we can’t see is exerting its gravitational force on everything we can see.

How to Find Dark Flow

Alexander Kashlinsky and his NASA team discovered dark flow by studying the cosmic microwave background (CMB). The CMB is electromagnetic radiation born from the big bang that blankets everything in the known universe like a uniform layer of static. When a galaxy cluster—a group of thousands of galaxies—moves through space, it drags high-energy electrons with it. These scatter the CMB radiation, disturbing it like the wake of a boat disturbs a lake. By searching for this disturbance, Kashlinsky’s team found evidence that all of the clusters they studied were moving toward a single point. They can’t see anything that would cause this bulk motion, so it may suggest that there is a very massive structure lurking beyond the edge of the visible universe pulling the galaxies toward it with its gravity.

So where is this big invisible thing? The latest cosmology models tend to assume that the universe is infinite and it’s just that we can only see part of it. Dark flow gives the first hint of what else might be out there, beyond the bounds of what can be observed directly from our solar system. It will be hard to learn more, though, since the source of the dark flow appears to be at least 46.5 billion light-years away, much farther than we can observe. Instead of trying to figure out how to peer beyond the visible universe, cosmologists are testing computer models of the universe’s evolution to pursue a possible cause of dark flow. Kashlinsky’s team is studying a new batch of data on the CMB and more galaxy clusters to refine their numbers. The more precise the observations, the better that theorists will be able to run simulations and test their ideas about what could be behind the mystery motion.

FAQ

Q. Where are the galaxies going?
A.
Cosmologists think the galaxies could be heading toward a very large primeval structure, but so far they aren’t speculating on what that might be. All the motion they’ve observed has been toward a 20-degree region of the sky, between the constellations Centaurus and Vela, so the unknown could be in that area.

Q. Is this mystery motion the same as dark energy and dark matter?
A.
Only in that they’re all mysterious forces. Fritz Zwicky discovered dark matter in 1933 when he measured the speed of galaxies orbiting in the outer edges of galaxy clusters. He found that there is too little visible mass in a cluster to produce the gravity required to keep the galaxies from flying off into space. The theoretically missing mass is called dark matter. Astronomers believe there is about five times as much dark matter in the universe as ordinary, visible matter.

The notion of dark energy came about in 1998, when scientists discovered that the universe is not only expanding, but it’s doing so faster than ever before. Physicists refer to whatever is powering this accelerated growth as dark energy. They estimate that the universe needs about three times as much energy as is stored in all known visible and dark matter combined to expand at its current rate.

Q. Could all these “dark” phenomena have the same cause?
A.
It’s unlikely. We could account for dark energy and dark matter by modifying our theory of gravity, or we could find new particles that explain them. But the particles would have to be different: Dark matter would require weakly interacting particles clustered within galaxies, while the particles causing dark energy would need to be distributed throughout the entire universe.

Want to read more articles on the military, aviation, and space? Subscribe to Popular Science and enter to win $5,000!

8 Comments

Reading this article makes me feel very very very very small.. ... just to think there is something out there beyond what we can see that's possibly bigger then even our universe that could have something to do with all these mysterious forces that we currently do not understand.. ..

its god inhaling duh

I always assumed the 3d universe exists in a larger multi dimensional construct. The three things listed could be the same cause. Picture a 2d plane with 2d creatures on it. In 3d you push up on the plane, they can't see or directly sense it but they can feel an interaction like a hill there (dark energy). Push down and it feels like a valley (dark matter).

Example is oversimplified and the interaction wouldn't be that direct, it would be an indirect spatial warping within the 2d or in our case 3d framework. But caused by another interaction within the higher dimensional spatial framework. The dark flow listed here could also be from that or a direct knurling up of space at the edges from inflation or interaction with another universes "bubble".

It doesn't have to just be a higher d space interacting with a lower d space like in the example. The interaction could also be caused by another 3d universe stacked within the higher dimensional framework. With its gravity attenuated through that higher d framework.

Either way cool stuff.

What makes them so certain it is Dark Flow. It could have been Dark Throw instead. They should be asking what has throw the galaxies away from.... could it result of a Baby Bang after a Big Bang?

A couple thoughts come to mind

One - what we call "empty space" is actually a medium we don't understand, that doesn't mix well with the material of our "universe". The two are like vinegar and oil. This would explain both the dark matter and dark energy dynamic in that the "oil" is both containing galaxy clusters and pushing them apart.

Two - none of our physics, which is based on observed motion, takes into account forces introduced from outside the "universe". The dark flow phenomenon illustrates that there is at least one source of such force. There are likely many more. One thing that seems consistent about the universe is its fractal nature. Repeating, similar patterns on various size scales.

Sokra,

Good question. You know it's a pull as opposed to a push because a push causes divergence whereas a pull creates convergence. What's been observed here is convergence, therefore, a pull.

Gary E. French

We are going home.

I'm glad to see some serious discussion about "the universe" existing beyond the 15 billion light-years that we can observe -- and that it might possibly be infinite. "The Large-Scale Streaming of Galaxies" by Alan Dresser, published in the Sept '87 issue of Scientific American, p 46, asserts that there must be some invisible Great Attractor out there somewhere causing the phenomenon.
Personally, I believe that (the) universe is infinite and it should be no surprise that there might be a few Great Attractors performing surprising gravitational feats in far-flung regions.
I have no comments directly about the possible nature of such a Great Attractor at this time, but I have thought long and hard about the possible nature of an infinite universe and how it might (probably does) work in perpetuity. I would be glad to give a copy of a book that I wrote and published, titled "The Nature of (the) Universe: The Role of Negative Mass in the Infinite Space of a Timeless and Stable, Dual-Gravity Universe", to anyone that asks nicely and convinces me that they are serious about reading it and sharing their own thoughts/research on the subject with me. If interested, contact me on herpatay@sover.net. Otherwise, it can be ordered through any bookstore by reference to ISBN 0-9707800-1-X.



Download Our iPhone App

Stay up to date on the latest news of the future of science and technology from your iPhone with full articles, images and offline viewing



Follow Us On Twitter

Featuring every article from the magazine and website, plus links from around the Web. Also see our PopSci DIY feed



Become a Fan On Facebook

Share links with friends, comment on stories and more


December 2009: Best of What's New

In our December issue, Popular Science names the 100 best innovations of the year: bombproof wallpaper, self-parking cars, the fastest helicopter, and 97 more. Plus inventor profiles and videos.

Check out the best of what's new here.

Popular Science Photo Pool


Share your photos in the Pop Sci pool at www.flickr.com!
tags_sprite.png
POP_embeddedForm_cover_May09.jpg