Concerns grow about the health of the aging hardware

What Spirit Saw NASA/JPL-Caltech

Like painted kites, those days and nights
went flyin' by

The world was new, beneath a blue
umbrella sky

Then softer than a piper man,
one day it called to you

And I lost you, I lost you to
the summer wind...

NASA engineers are hoping those words, famously crooned by Frank Sinatra, don't come true this summer for the unflappable Mars rovers, Spirit and Opportunity.

Summer is approaching on Mars, and with it comes the onset of huge wind storms that kick dust around the twin Mars Exploration Rovers and their life-giving solar panels. A storm in July 2007, nearly one Martian year ago, blocked 99 percent of the rovers' sunlight. The storms don't happen every year, but when they do, they start about this time -- on Tuesday, April 21, Mars will be at the closest point to the sun in its 23-month year, and the official start of summer comes a month later.

Scientists at NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory and at offices in San Diego and College Station, Texas, are keeping an eye on the warming Martian weather, ready to tell the rovers to rest in advance of a dust storm.

They're still healthy, but like the fittest human, the rovers are not immune from the symptoms of aging. Spirit is having some memory problems, and has had some "senior moments" when its computer rebooted unexpectedly a couple times in the past week. Spirit talked to its controllers on Earth Friday, April 10, through Sunday, April 12, but some of the communications were irregular, according to JPL. The rover apparently reset its computer in the midst of using its dish antenna to communicate with Earth. It has also had some memory gaps in which it's not properly saving data.

John Callas, project manager for Spirit and Opportunity, based at JPL, said Spirit's batteries are charged, the solar arrays are working fine and the rover seems healthy, despite the unusual activity. It is in an automatic mode to take care of itself, and can stay in that mode for some time while engineers figure out what's wrong.

The rovers' software has been upgraded several times in the five years since their mission had been scheduled to end. The latest upgrade was last month, and mission managers are investigating whether that put Spirit on the fritz -- even though Opportunity, halfway across the planet with the same software, is operating just fine.

"We are aware of the reality that we have an aging rover, and there may be age-related effects here," Callas acknowledged.

The rovers have been going strong since January 2004 on a mission that was supposed to last just 90 days. Martian winds are partly to thank for that, because a stiff breeze can help clear dust off the rovers' solar panels.

In February, wind cleared enough dust off Spirit's panels to nearly double its power-gathering capacity. And earlier this month, wind helped increase Opportunity's electrical output by 40 percent. The rovers use about 180 watt-hours per day for basic survival and communications, according to NASA.

But that same wind can cause harm by blocking out the sun. If scientists can anticipate a big storm, they can back off power-eating communications sessions and tell the rovers to stay put. The Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter, which reached the Red Planet in 2006, helps with that.

MRO's Mars Color Imager can see the entire planet every day at a resolution comparable to Earth weather satellites, which allows Bruce Cantor, with the Color Imager team, to provide frequent weather reports. On Nov. 8, Cantor warned the rover team of a dust storm nearing Spirit, and the team was able to lessen Spirit's workload to help save energy, JPL said. Without taking those precautions, Spirit's batteries could have dwindled to dangerously low levels.

As they watch for dust storms, engineers hope the fickle summer wind blows their way and helps clean off Spirit and Opportunity, rather than burying them in more dust.

"We're all hoping we'll get another good cleaning," said Bill Nelson, chief engineer for the rovers at JPL.

Want to read more articles on the military, aviation, and space? Subscribe to Popular Science and enter to win $5,000!

3 Comments

Wow.......didn't even realize they were still "alive". Considering NASA developed their experiments around a 90 day life cycle, I bet their longevity has been a real budget buster. Thanks for the update.

It was their 5 year anniversary in Dec 2008. Pretty amazing that they are still going. Spirit is dragging a bum wheel and they both are experiencing old age issues. They have driven over 14 miles combined. Value for money, this mission has been a stunning success.

Mike Cook

from Kent, WA

Both these rovers have had remarkable careers, but it is worth mentioning that the insistence on making them solar powered has really limited the amount of terrain they could cover, the science they could do, and the rate at which they could transmit information back to Earth. In fact, a great number of highly-paid people have had to nurse these rovers along for years on the tiny trickle of solar energy their limited (and dust-covered) solar panels produce. The sheer lack of juice has limited the number and quality of photos sent back to our planet.

In Martian winter the rovers have been virtually parked. In bad dust storms they are parked, because not enough solar energy gets through to run your TV remote.

If, in place of the solar panels and attendant batteries, small nuclear fission piles had been developed, the rovers could have been much more robust--traveling further, faster, and not having to worry about being in the shadows of hills or storing up enough energy to navigate through a dark canyon with enough energy left in the batteries to actually do some observations or experiments. Both the Russians and ourselves used nuclear power in the past and are facing the near-absolute necessity of using it when going beyond Jupiter, but it seems like the technology gets under-utilized in a lot of applications where it would make a great deal of sense, such as on Mars surface vehicles.

Nuclear "batteries" eventually run out too, but while active they put out an enormous amount of power that can do an enormous amount of research, leaving program scientists free to think about Mars itself instead of daily trying to solve the severe problems that rovers handicapped by a serious lack of power have constantly got themselves into.



Download Our iPhone App

Stay up to date on the latest news of the future of science and technology from your iPhone with full articles, images and offline viewing



Follow Us On Twitter

Featuring every article from the magazine and website, plus links from around the Web. Also see our PopSci DIY feed



Become a Fan On Facebook

Share links with friends, comment on stories and more


December 2009: Best of What's New

In our December issue, Popular Science names the 100 best innovations of the year: bombproof wallpaper, self-parking cars, the fastest helicopter, and 97 more. Plus inventor profiles and videos.

Check out the best of what's new here.

Popular Science Photo Pool


Share your photos in the Pop Sci pool at www.flickr.com!
tags_sprite.png
POP_embeddedForm_cover_May09.jpg